Do you agree with Nemur, Strauss, or Charlie about telling Mr. Donner? Support your answer with reasons.

HOOKS
10/4/2011 11:27:41 am

Charlie did the moral thing people should do. he made gimpy think for himself also of his actions. Third person example.

Reply
10/5/2011 07:01:28 am

I agree with Charlie about saying something to Mr. Donner the only thing is, he has no evidencs to soppurt what he discoverd. I so think, that him talking to Gimpsy was a good idea, that way he soesn't feel so bad not reacting to Gimpy stealing from Mr Donner.

Reply
Zuhey Alamos
10/5/2011 01:01:25 pm

I agree with Charlie because he's concience is telling and he wouldnt feel right if he kept to himself. So morally speaking he did the right thing. And that way he won't have any guilt and he will have his concience appeased.

Reply
Anissia Ramos
10/5/2011 01:59:35 pm

I agree with Alice's advice.I think Alice gave him the confidence he needed to make the decision he did. I also found it quite interesting how Charlie told Gimpy how he knew he was stealing.

Reply
Adesunbo Akinsalami
10/5/2011 03:03:57 pm

Sometimes it's good to let a criminal convicts himself and that was what Charlie did to Gimpy.He made Gimpy to judge himself and he gave him the opportunity to change.Charlie did not ignored the situation.I fully agreed with Charlie.

Reply
Alex Ortiz
10/5/2011 04:31:35 pm

I agree with charlie he fills Mr. Donner has helped him out quite a bit and he realized what gimpy was doing and its wrong. Charlie didnt want anything to do with that. In my opinion charlie went for advice to alice just to see her, but she did give him the right advice.

Reply
rashada wills
11/4/2011 01:16:43 pm

i believe that charlie should tell mr. donner it is the only right thing to do and if he does not then i feel that he is going to have problems especially with his concience and that feeling i know would not be good for charlie especially in the state of mind that he is in at the moment.

Reply



Leave a Reply.